"Who watches the watchmen?"
Opacity is disaffecting in all relationships, whether interpersonal or between an individual and an organization. Opaque and its synonyms are never numbered in the characteristics of The Savior. Unfortunately, the same can't be said of virtually all churches. Decisions are disassociated from those who made them by seemingly endless layers of abstraction and obfuscation. Any who believe that this isn't the case haven't spent much time in churches of above about 300 attenders.
Why is this an issue? Those of us with inquisitive minds tend to believe that things are only hidden when there's "something to hide". Humanity labels those who generically hide information, facts, behaviors, decisions, etc. as "paranoid". We view them as odd or even dangerous. Which is true of the average church. Is there something to hide? Are we paranoid, and therefore "mentally ill" as an organization?
At the root of this issue is accountability. Quite literally, "Who watches the watchmen". Those who would say they are "accountable to God" for their decisions scare me. HORRIBLE things have been done by those claiming this sole accountability. In reality, this is no accountability at all. In cases where claims of accountability are made, attempting to determine what the accountability relationships look like only reveals further opacity. All too often these are circular accountabilities at best.
I once attended a church where the financial audit required in the church bylaws was voted down at the pastor's suggestion. It was declared a waste of money. During the open discussion time, I posited that it should be done and made available to any who wished to see it as a witness to the community of our church's transparency, accountability, and stewardship. I was looked at as though I'd suggested that we hire Martians to do the audit as well. I alone presented a view and vote contrary to the leadership. Not too long after, I was offered "the left foot of Christian fellowship" out of that organization. I was told I "questioned the pastor too much" and could no longer serve there.
What does it say about us that we decry the misdeeds of "the world", yet are unwilling to open our books and our decision making to open scrutiny? Decisions are made, finances are allocated, yet determining "where the buck stops" can be virtually impossible.
This behavior alone screams hypocrisy to those we are commanded to reach. It undermines any claims we make to "moral high ground", or even a "more righteous way". We must make transparency our personal and our corporate hallmark. We've been told time and time again that "transparency breeds trust". It's in every relationship book we've been sold. It's past time that this sound advice be adopted in our organizational relationships as well.
No comments:
Post a Comment